UGHHHH!! I hate admitting when I am wrong (We can call this personality flaw number 1). Over the past couple of days as I have been reading the info for Thing 7, a comment I made a few weeks back keeps going through my mind over and over and over again. Ever have one of those moments when you just wanted to hit the rewind button only to realize that your mouth doesn’t have one? Or perhaps like me you’ve made a comment and then failed to do a good job explaining your comment. Well, here is what happened. A teacher here reserved the media center so that her students could do research for a class project. As I do with any group of students doing research, I introduced several options for gathering info including print and non-print media. I even mentioned Wikipedia — with a caution to avoid them if possible. (I know you are cringing also right about now.) I missed a great opportunity to instruct the students in techniques of evaluating online material. Where is that rewind button again? Oh yes, I don’t have one. Therefore I must admit that I made a HUGE blunder. I missed a great chance for a teachable moment. Shame on me. I am, however, going to take the fact that I recognize this error as a sign that there is still hope for this media specialist!
I enjoyed reading Vicki Davis’ blog post entitled Wiki Wiki Teaching. I was challenged by her enthusiasm to give something new a try and was encouraged by the success she outlined in her blog. I wasn’t unfamiliar with Vicki Davis as her blogs is one that I now subscribe to on Google Reader. Her enthusiasm for Web 2.0 is contagious. I think that I am a bit envious of her trailblazer spirit in this area.
As instructed, I took a look around at some of the wikis in our Thing 7 list. The FHS Wolves Den wiki was interesting to me. I liked the organization with current tasks and assignments at the top while a glimpse of where the class had been was still on the page. With little credit given to actual students, it was difficult for me to see where the teacher’s input stopped and the students started.
Turn Homeward, Hannah Lee is a wiki created by 5th grade reading students and provides insight to the novel written by Patricial Beatty. This wiki truly seemed to epitomize the collaborative effort of a couple of different classes and many different students. The student created slide shows really provided a means to see the talent level of the students as well as highlighted their interest in the class project. I would imagine that many parents, grandparents and other extended family members got an invite to see the student’s work online.
One of the wikis that I liked the least was the Thousand Projects wiki. I didn’t disagree with the premise, but perhaps I misunderstood the ultimate purpose of the wiki. Why was 1,000 the goal? How are the contributions being utilized in the classroom? Is the exercise considered a failure if fewer than 1,000 responses were received?
After looking at many of these wikis, I have begun to wonder how I can implement a wiki into my media center. Enter Barry. Barry is a new student at our school this year. I enjoy talking with Barry. However, he is a literature snob. I use that term affectionately because I truly enjoy the fact that he loves to read — even though he is very vocal about what he would call formulaic trash (which most students around here prefer to read when reading is required.) Often as students will, I am asked where to find a ”good book”. Being somewhat book snobbish myself, I catch myself from pointing out that we have thousands of books on our library shelves and that they are all good books. After a process of ascertaining a students personal interests I make several suggestions and pull books only to get the, “I don’t think I would like that.” Book cover not pleasing enough, too many pages, whatever the reason they don’t like the books. However, on more than one occasion this year I have seen one of these students with whom I have had these book discussions leaving with a book that I had previously suggested. When I make the comment, “Oh you decided to try my suggestion anyway.” I get this: “No, Barry says its a good book.” Barry, Barry, Barry!!! So this is what I am going to try to do. I will create a wiki (that in my mind I will call “Barry’s Place”), and get students here to post book recommendations. Of course, Barry will be the first person I invite to join. Recommendations will include a short summary and why the student thinks the book should be read by others. This will help me also when I can’t match a kid face to face with Barry, they can just go to the wiki and read his recommendations. Thanks Barry for being the catalyst for a new day in the media center.